In 2005, a psychologist gave me a test to see if I was suffering from gender identity disorder. The test consisted of questions such as, "Would you rather be a nurse or a mechanic?", and, "Do you enjoy wearing makeup?" The doctor said that the answers I gave did not indicate any gender identity issues, and she made me feel as if discussing the matter any further would be a waste of her time. The questions on the test were written from a hopelessly outdated and rigidly heteronormative perspective, and the psychologist was obviously uninformed and ill-equipped to deal with that kind of issue, so I dropped it. At the time, I just needed my meds, and, being without insurance, my choice of providers was limited.
But I didn't forget about it. How could I? I've had dreams that I was male ever since I was little. I still have those dreams on a regular basis. In dreams in which I have a male body, I feel free and unburdened and better than I have ever felt in waking life.
I reached out, talked about it, got to know many transgendered people. I even went to a transgender support group with my then-girlfriend. After a lot of research and some serious soul-searching, I made the decision to see how I felt presenting myself as male. That is why I originally changed my name to Morgan.
I had fun as a boy. I passed remarkably well, considering the size of my tits. I absolutely loved it when people addressed me as "sir," and kids referred to me as "that guy with purple hair." Ultimately, though, it felt artificial. I attribute this to the fact that, in order to pass as male, I had to turn the butch dial all the way past 11. When I was forced to move back home with my mother, I abandoned any attempt to present as male, because it just wasn't worth the hassle of trying to get her to understand.
Though I didn't present as male anymore, I had still "transitioned" from Heather to Morgan, and I consider that, in itself, a triumph. Morgan was me. Heather was someone else, someone my mother invented, someone my peers and teachers and bosses and partners had forced me to be against my will. Morgan is who I always have been. I often joke that I am a queer man in a woman's body who enjoys dressing in drag.
It isn't really a joke.
If you are stuck in a gender binary mindset, none of this probably makes any sense to you. If you have never encountered a man who dresses in drag for fun and not because he wants to be a woman, you're probably thinking, "So what's the probem?" (Also, note that it is nearly impossible for woman to dress "in drag" because ... well, I could write a paper on that.)
Imagine it this way. You have a favorite outfit that you wear when you go out for special occasions. You look great in it, and you always get compliments on it. You like the way it looks, but it's not the most comfortable thing in the world, and it requires lots of preparation, so it's not for every day. When you just want to relax, it stays in the closet (no pun intended), and you wear whatever is most comfortable. Now, imagine that you have to wear that outfit, or one very similar to it, for the rest of your life, and it doesn't disappear even when you take off your clothes.
If I had been born male, I would enjoy wearing a "special outfit" on weekends. I'd be the kind of guy who isn't ashamed to look fabulous. I might even dress in drag. But I'd shelve my tits and put my wig away when I was at home, just being me. I'd probably dress pretty plainly for every-day goings-on, only occasionally breaking out those cute pumps to go shopping in, just because. I would still date mostly men. Mostly. I mean, I get along with boys better than I do with girls for the most part, but I still find women very attractive. Who knows. Maybe I'd even date more women, since I'd have a cock of my own to play with. Whatever. Gender identity is not the same as sexual orientation. You knew that, right?
Fabulous or not, I fit the definition of transgender because I identify with a gender other than my biological one. Sometimes, I actually envy trans folk who happen to fit the gender binary. A really butch girl becomes a boy, a really femme boy becomes a girl. Of course, it's never really that straight-forward, and I don't mean to undermine the incredible fortitude it takes for any individual to transition. It's just that my gender does not exist in a list of neat little check-boxes, and in a world that is still largely stuck in a heteronormative paradigm, there isn't really a place for me, or those like me. (I do know of others.) I'm in the minority of a minority. Par for the course.
Outside, I am Morgan, the woman. Inside, I am Morgan, the man. I can't even climax during sex unless I visualize having a penis. (Freud would have a field day with me.) So why didn't I just go through with a transition? Get a double-mastectomy, maybe look into some hormone treatment, and possibly genital surgery? Why? Because I think that stuff would make me feel even more like a freak. I was "gifted" with a
Beyond any of that, probably the biggest reason I never sought a medical solution is because I care about the people around me. This may sound strange, but it's the same mechanism that has prevented me from attempting suicide in my darkest moments. If I were to fully, physically and legally transition, I would essentially be killing the girl to give life to the boy. Though many of my loved ones already know of my gender issues and would be supportive, there are other things to consider. How would I explain this to my in-laws? How would it affect my husband's well-being and reputation? I don't like my mother, but I must still consider her feelings, and having her drop dead of a heart attack isn't on my list of things to do today. But yeah, if it was just me, if I had no one to consider but myself (and I happened to be a millionaire), I probably would have done it years ago.
My spirituality is my saving grace in all of this. It allows for fluidity in gender and gender expression. Some Native American traditions may have identified me as a Two-Spirit, and I embrace this idea. I believe in reincarnation, if not in a linear fashion, then at least in shared memory. Perhaps I am remembering maleness from another life. Maybe this is the first time I've ever been a woman, and I'm just not used to it. Regardless, I cling to the idea that I have a purpose in this life as a female-bodied individual. In spite of all, I am happily married to a wonderful man. Maybe that's why I was born in this body-- because I was meant to marry this man, who is supportive and loving, but not gay. Even if he was gay, and I was legally male, we couldn't have married in Ohio, so there's that. But having a wonderful, stable relationship has not erased this part of me.
So what to do? I don't know. Probably nothing. It feels better just to get it out there in black and white, talk about it, let it breathe instead of denying its existence. I am nothing if not adaptable, and that is something I have always been proud of. I know who I am inside, and that's what counts.
FWIW, I don't think you are "trans-gendered." I think you are "pan-gendered," to coin a term.
ReplyDeleteThis doesn't make you any less out of sync with cultural norms (totally artificial as THEY are) but the different viewpoint creates different approaches to self-actualization. And that's the whole point really--getting all of you as congruent with all you are, as much as possible.
This statement seems particularly germane to me:
"Also, note that it is nearly impossible for woman to dress "in drag" because ... well, I could write a paper on that"
It pinpoints the problem. It's not just physical presentation, it's everything. Androgynous men are still very clearly men. Androgynous women are simply confusing, because every definition of "feminine" present in the English language boils down to "not masculine."
Unfuck that.
The pervasiveness of this contextual absurdity can be annoying, frustrating, even crippling, but one's "gender" is like any other limitation. I think part of what handicaps pan-gendered people--physical limitations aside--is buying into the myth of gender dichotomy, and then allowing that belief to shape their self-awareness.
You are "Morgan the Very Complex." Create your own paradigm. Display whatever facets of your true and authentic self are appropriate in any given situation. Call them "female," because you're female. You define the behavior; the behavior doesn't define you.
My $1.02.
Mandy
Mandy,
ReplyDeleteI agree with almost everything you've said. However, it isn't all about presentation. When I am alone, I still look at my body and feel that it is incomplete and grossly out-of-proportion to the person I am inside. I work with what I have, which is a female body, but the physical dysmorphism can't be fixed with how I choose to "present." Maybe my last paragraph was waxing a little bit poetic. I think I'm going to edit it for clarity.
-M
ETA because I can never leave well enough alone: Perhaps you are a hermaphrodite with a physical birth defect—your phallus simply didn't develop properly.
ReplyDeleteWouldn't that be cool? Maybe my ovaries don't work properly because one of them is a testicle. :P
ReplyDelete"I still look at my body and feel that it is incomplete and grossly out-of-proportion to the person I am inside"
ReplyDeleteI'm grateful that my sexuality has so little to do with the characteristics of my sex organs, except mechanically. It's too bloody complicated already.
I get the mismatched insides/outsides though. I'm at least six feet tall. I have broad shoulders, big breasts, and perfect teeth. My skin is greenish and hairless; it looks and feels like silk.
I've had to get used to a body that's stunted, dumpy, and lumpy, pink, and missing a tail, but it will never be an accurate representation, and I'll never be happy about it.
Ooohhh don't EVEN get me started on the metaphysical part. That's something I won't even discuss with my therapist.
ReplyDeleteI stated this already, but might as well say it here too. I love you, each and every part of you, and it does not and will not erase the loving, stable relationship.
ReplyDeleteyou, are my sibling spouse and no matter what I love you.... as does everyone here
ReplyDelete